The National Rifle Association’s key talking point rolled out as predictably as the sad reality that another mass shooting will happen soon in a U.S. school.
“This is not the time to discuss gun control.”
Let’s add just one word to the key talking point: This is not the ONLY time to discuss gun control.
In fact, it’s EXACTLY the time.
The add-on to the “Now is not the time…” argument usually goes something like this: “The dead aren’t even cold yet, and you want to turn it into an argument for gun control. Shame on you.”
This illogical and dispassionate reasoning has been repeated across social media and echoed through the halls of the U.S. Congress since the February 14 slaying of 17 people at a Florida high school. The speaker of the House provided a representative sound bite in a news conference the next day.
“This is not the time to jump to some conclusion not knowing the full facts,” he said. “This is one of those moments where we just need to step back and count our blessings.”
It’s not exactly clear which blessings he was talking about. It’s a good bet a lot of parents, siblings, spouses, grandparents and friends haven’t been feeling especially blessed since last Wednesday.
As for the dead children in Parkland, Fla., they’re not counting or feeling anything anymore.
Would the people who use the “Now is not the time…” argument change their tunes if it was their husband, father, son, daughter, sister or brother lying on the school’s hallway floor? Would it change their minds about gun control? Or anything else?
Because one thing’s clear – something has to change.
Purveyors of the “Now is not the time…” argument often follow it up with, “Besides, mass shootings have nothing to do with guns. The real issue is mental health.”
Mental health is an issue in this country, certainly. It undoubtedly contributes to many problems, including gun violence.
So, let’s talk about mental health. Let’s talk about availability, affordability and access to mental health care. Let’s talk about reasonable, effective gun control legislation, as well.
In fact, let’s talk about every issue that qualified experts identify as contributing to mass shootings in the United States. They should all be on the table.
More importantly, let’s finally do something.
As the dead are mourned in Florida, the real questions are these: If we shouldn’t talk about these issues now, then when? If we don’t go beyond talk to take action now, then when? If we don’t stop the killing of our children, who will?
Because it’s shame on us all if we don’t.
We call our country great, and in so many ways it is. But we won’t be able to say so for long if we stand by as our children are slaughtered in their schools.
Stop. Really think about that.
Our children. Slaughtered. In their schools.
Now is not the ONLY time. Now is EXACTLY the time.
* In the meantime, I’ll be using the hashtag #NRANoWay wherever I can and withholding my vote from any politician who belongs to or takes money from the NRA. Please join me.
CNN: 2018 School Shootings
Feb. 14: Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. (17 people killed, 14 injured)
Feb. 5: Oxon Hill High School in Prince George’s County, Maryland (1 student injured)
Feb. 1: Salvador Castro Middle School in Los Angeles, California. (2 students shot)
Jan. 23: Marshall County High School in in Benton, Kentucky (2 students killed, 18 injured)
Jan. 22: NET Charter High School in New Orleans, Louisiana (1 student injured)
Jan. 22: Italy High School in Italy, Texas (1 student injured)
Jan. 10: Coronado Elementary School in Sierra Vista, Arizona (1 student killed)
A Centrist Democrat's Presumption - IV Words - The Progressive Perspective · December 15, 2021 at 8:33 am
[…] There are more guns in the USA than there are people. […]
Honorary Minnesotazenship - IV Words - The Progressive Perspe · February 6, 2021 at 3:46 pm
[…] The perennial favorites are there, too, like making it easier to buy, carry and conceal guns. Always with the guns. […]
#4 - I Am A Progressive - · October 28, 2020 at 5:23 pm
[…] climate crisis. Police brutality. Women’s rights. Guns. Incarceration inequality. Rigged courts and proceedings. The rights of Black, Indigenous and People […]
#NRANoWay and other thoughts on gun control | Kevin Brooks · February 20, 2018 at 4:03 am
[…] via Let’s Add One Word to the Talking Point […]